The Voodoo Security System in Second Life has earned a reputation as a
griefing tool, and for good reason. The creator of Voodoo Security System once
used it as a weapon against avatars belonging to a specific group in Second
Life, the Greenzone group. This manipulation of the system for personal
vendettas highlights the darker side of virtual world security systems.
The Emergence of the Greenzone Group
The Greenzone group in Second Life was formed in response to privacy concerns
stemming from the controversial RedZone system. RedZone was a tool that
tracked users’ IP addresses through a feature in Second Life’s media streaming
service. This allowed it to identify alternate accounts (alts), which violated
the privacy of residents who wished to keep their alts anonymous. The use of
RedZone raised alarms among Second Life users who felt their privacy was being
compromised, leading to the creation of the Greenzone group as a
countermeasure to protect user privacy. (link to source: https://nwn.blogs.com/nwn/2011/02/redzone-ip-controversy-second-life.html)
I joined the Greenzone group years ago because I shared these concerns. I
wanted to stay informed about potential privacy violations and protect myself
from similar threats. Today, I still remain deeply concerned about privacy
issues in Second Life, and it’s something I believe should be a priority for
the community and developers alike.
The Voodoo Security System’s Misuse
When I returned to Second Life after a few years away, I was shocked to find
that I had been banned by the Voodoo Security System. The system notified me
that my avatar had been added to its ban list, but I couldn’t understand why.
I hadn’t caused any issues or acted in a way that would warrant such a ban.
Initially, I assumed it was a mistake, and I shrugged it off, thinking it was
just a random glitch or error.
However, after a bit of investigation, I realized the reason for my ban was
likely tied to my membership in the Greenzone group. The creator of the Voodoo
Security System had an issue with Greenzone and its members, and it became
clear that they had used the system to target everyone in the group.
Personal Vendettas and the Abuse of Power
It turns out that the creator of Voodoo Security System had personal
grievances with the Greenzone group. According to a post on the Second Life
forums, the creator made an ultimatum to Greenzone members: leave the group
within 24 hours or be added to the Voodoo Security System’s ban list. This
move was a blatant abuse of power, using a tool that was intended to protect
avatars as a method of retaliation against a group they disagreed with. (link
to source: https://community.secondlife.com/forums/topic/485311-please-i-need-to-get-unbanned-from-voodoo-security/page/4/)
This post further confirmed that the Voodoo Security System had been
weaponized to target a specific group based solely on their association with
Greenzone. This was an egregious misuse of a security system that should have
been neutral and impartial, but instead was turned into a tool for griefing.
The Flawed Logic Behind Collective Punishment
The most troubling aspect of this situation is the concept of collective
punishment. The Voodoo Security System didn’t care whether an individual had
done anything wrong—it punished everyone in the Greenzone group. This is
absurd and unjust. It’s akin to saying that if you are White, you must be a
slave owner, even though most White people had no involvement in slavery. This
form of punishment is deeply flawed because it punishes people for their group
affiliation rather than their individual actions.
Such collective punishment has no place in a virtual world that promotes
freedom of expression and personal agency. The entire purpose of the Greenzone
group was to protect privacy, but instead, its members became targets of
harassment.
My Continued Experience in Second Life
Even after learning the cause of my ban, the effects still linger. I continue
to be kicked out of locations in Second Life, places I’ve never even visited
before. It’s frustrating because there’s no clear explanation for why this is
happening, and my memory isn’t perfect, so I struggle to remember which places
I’m banned from. I wish there were a way to block those locations permanently
so that I wouldn’t accidentally try to visit them again.
While this situation has gotten easier to deal with over time, it remains an
ongoing reminder of the harm that can be caused when security tools are abused
for personal reasons. I am not the only person who has encountered this
problem—other members of the Greenzone group have shared similar experiences
of being banned by the Voodoo Security System without cause. It’s a reminder
that in Second Life, as in real life, power can be misused by those who
control the tools.
Testing the System’s Detection Methods
In an attempt to understand how the Voodoo Security System detected alts, I
decided to experiment. I created two alternate accounts: one with media
enabled and one with media turned off. As expected, the account with media
turned on was banned by the Voodoo system, while the other, with media turned
off, was not. This suggests that the Voodoo Security System may rely on media
settings and IP addresses to track avatars, which is troubling, as it opens
the door for privacy violations similar to those caused by RedZone.
The Enduring Problem of Abuse
The main issue here is the potential for continued abuse of the Voodoo
Security System. Even if the system is no longer in widespread use, the
possibility remains that it could still be used inappropriately. If someone
with malicious intent has access to the Voodoo Security System, they could
easily add someone to the ban list and disrupt their experience in Second
Life. This highlights the need for greater transparency and safeguards around
virtual world security systems. No system should be open to such abuse,
especially one that affects people’s ability to participate in the virtual
community.
In My Humble Opinion
The Voodoo Security System, which was originally designed to protect avatars
in Second Life, became a tool for griefing when it was weaponized by its
creator against the Greenzone group. This abuse of power resulted in innocent
avatars being punished simply for their association with a group focused on
protecting privacy. The system was misused in a way that undermined the
principles of fairness and justice in Second Life. While the abuse of such
tools may have lessened over time, it serves as a cautionary tale of the
dangers that arise when powerful systems are used for personal vendettas
instead of the greater good.
FTC Disclosure: This post or video contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through my links.
